SafeUM
Home Blog Services Download Help About Recharge
EN
RU

Axarhöfði 14, 110 Reykjavik, Iceland

Iceland - 2015
SafeUM
Blog
Services
Download
Help
About
Recharge
Menu
EN
Lang
EN
RU
Archive
TOP Security!
11 Sep 2015

Microsoft urges US court to block warrant for emails held abroad

Microsoft Corp asked a federal appeals court on Wednesday to block the US government from forcing the company to hand over a customer's emails stored on an Irish server, warning that the precedent would create a "global free-for-all" that eviscerates personal privacy.

The case, the first in which a US company has challenged a warrant seeking data held abroad, has captured the attention of the technology industry, privacy advocates and news organizations.

The appeal is centered on a search warrant seeking the emails of an individual in Dublin, as part of a drug investigation. The person has not been identified. Joshua Rosenkranz, a lawyer for Microsoft, warned the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals in New York that upholding the warrant would open the door to other countries using their law enforcement powers to seize the emails of Americans held in the United States. "We would go crazy if China did this to us," Rosenkranz said.

But Justin Anderson, a lawyer for the government, said US law enforcement can obtain electronic information held by American companies with a valid warrant, regardless of where the data happens to be stored. "It's not a question of ownership," he said, likening it to seizing account records from a bank. "It's about custody and control." Nearly 100 organizations and individuals filed briefs in support of Microsoft's position, including tech giants like Apple Inc, Verizon Communications Inc and Cisco Systems Inc and media companies like McClatchy Co and Gannett Co Inc.

The three-judge panel directed tough questions at both sides, giving little indication of how it will eventually rule. The statute at issue, the Stored Communications Act, was enacted in 1986, decades before providers like Microsoft began building servers abroad to improve speed.

The question is whether the warrant is an "extraterritorial" application of the law, as Microsoft contends, or whether the fact that US-based Microsoft security employees can retrieve the data means the statute is being used only within the United States, as the government argues.

"This was a pre-CompuServe, pre-AOL world" when the law was passed, Rosenkranz said, urging the court to leave it to Congress to close what he said was a gap in the law. Circuit Judge Gerald Lynch agreed that legislative action would be best but noted wryly that Congress does not always act quickly.

"We'll all be holding our breath," he said with a smile. The case is In the Matter of a Warrant to Search a Certain E-mail Account Controlled and Maintained by Microsoft Corp, 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 14-2985. Earlier Apple and other tech companies tangle with US over data access.

Tags:
Microsoft USA surveillance
Source:
Reuters
1504
Other NEWS
3 Jul 2020 safeum news imgage An encrypted messaging service has been infiltrated by police
4 May 2020 safeum news imgage Two-Factor Authentication ​What Is It and Why You Should Use It
12 Dec 2019 safeum news imgage Encryption is under threat - this is how it affects you
4 Nov 2019 safeum news imgage Should Big Decisions Be Based on Data or Your Intuition?
7 Jun 2018 safeum news imgage VPNFilter malware infecting 500,000 devices is worse than we thought
4 Jun 2018 safeum news imgage Hackers target Booking.com in criminal bid to steal hundreds of thousands from customers
1 Jun 2018 safeum news imgage Operator of World's Top Internet Hub Sues German Spy Agency
30 May 2018 safeum news imgage US says North Korea behind malware attacks
29 May 2018 safeum news imgage Facebook and Google targeted as first GDPR complaints filed
25 May 2018 safeum news imgage A new reason to not buy these cheap Android devices
24 May 2018 safeum news imgage Flaws in smart pet devices, apps could come back to bite owners
23 May 2018 safeum news imgage Google sued for 'clandestine tracking' of 4.4m UK iPhone users' browsing data
21 May 2018 safeum news imgage LocationSmart reportedly leaked phone location data onto the web
18 May 2018 safeum news imgage The SEC created its own scammy ICO to teach investors a lesson
17 May 2018 safeum news imgage Thieves suck millions out of Mexican banks in transfer heist
All news
SafeUM
Confidential Terms of Use Our technologies Company
Follow us
Download
SafeUM © Safe Universal Messenger

Axarhöfði 14,
110 Reykjavik, Iceland

Iceland - 2015