SafeUM
Home Blog Services Download Help About Recharge

Axarhöfði 14, 110 Reykjavik, Iceland

Iceland - 2015
SafeUM
Blog
Services
Download
Help
About
Recharge
Menu
Archive
TOP Security!
24 Feb 2016

FBI chief 'not trying to set precedent' with shooter's iPhone

FBI Director James Comey has penned an editorial about its dispute with Apple over unlocking the iPhone of San Bernardino shooter Syed Rizwan Farook.

In it, he tried to quell criticism by Apple's Tim Cook that a court's decision forcing Apple to help the FBI access the device could have "chilling" implications. "The San Bernardino litigation isn't about trying to set a precedent or send any kind of message," says Comey.

"We don't want to break anyone's encryption or set a master key loose on the land. It is about the victims and justice. We owe them a thorough and professional investigation." Apple pricked a hole in the "professional" part of the investigation, however. It said the whole issue could have been avoided had the government not mistakenly reset the passcode on the shooter's device. In that case, the company would have been able to hand over the data from iCloud after the device was backed up. As it stands now, the only way for the government to get access to the data is by forcing Apple to update the shooter's phone with a crippled version of iOS. The agency could then try numerous passcodes until they stumble on the right one.

Google, Facebook and other tech companies, along with the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) and ACLU have come out on Apple's side in the dispute. Numerous news sites have also penned editorials favoring Apple's stance, including the NYT, Washington Post and Engadget. As a result, law enforcement agencies like the FBI are increasingly making their case in public -- the Department of Justice tried to reduce Apple's stance to a "marketing strategy," for instance.

The issue 'should not be resolved by corporations that sell stuff for a living,' says Comey. Comey says early on in his editorial that "the particular legal issue is actually quite narrow. The relief we seek is limited and its value increasingly obsolete because the technology continues to evolve." However, he then pleads his case for general access to encrypted devices, saying that only the public, and not Apple or the FBI can solve the "tension" between security and privacy.

"That tension should not be resolved by corporations that sell stuff for a living. It also should not be resolved by the FBI, which investigates for a living. It should be resolved by the American people deciding how we want to govern ourselves in a world we have never seen before."

That's the same message Comey has been sending for the past several years: The FBI must have some way to defeat encryption in order to fight terrorism and other threats. However, security experts say that such holes will make everyone, including the government, less protected. And while Comey says that the legal issue is narrow, critics argue that a judgement against Apple would set a precedent that could open the floodgates to similar requests.

The FBI and DoJ may or may not have the support of the general public on the issue, but they do have the backing of the San Bernardino victims. Some of them will file a brief in support of the FBI's effort to force Apple to unlock the shooter's phone.

Tags:
Apple surveillance FBI
Source:
Engadget
1826
Other NEWS
3 Jul 2020 safeum news imgage An encrypted messaging service has been infiltrated by police
4 May 2020 safeum news imgage Two-Factor Authentication ​What Is It and Why You Should Use It
12 Dec 2019 safeum news imgage Encryption is under threat - this is how it affects you
4 Nov 2019 safeum news imgage Should Big Decisions Be Based on Data or Your Intuition?
7 Jun 2018 safeum news imgage VPNFilter malware infecting 500,000 devices is worse than we thought
4 Jun 2018 safeum news imgage Hackers target Booking.com in criminal bid to steal hundreds of thousands from customers
1 Jun 2018 safeum news imgage Operator of World's Top Internet Hub Sues German Spy Agency
30 May 2018 safeum news imgage US says North Korea behind malware attacks
29 May 2018 safeum news imgage Facebook and Google targeted as first GDPR complaints filed
25 May 2018 safeum news imgage A new reason to not buy these cheap Android devices
24 May 2018 safeum news imgage Flaws in smart pet devices, apps could come back to bite owners
23 May 2018 safeum news imgage Google sued for 'clandestine tracking' of 4.4m UK iPhone users' browsing data
21 May 2018 safeum news imgage LocationSmart reportedly leaked phone location data onto the web
18 May 2018 safeum news imgage The SEC created its own scammy ICO to teach investors a lesson
17 May 2018 safeum news imgage Thieves suck millions out of Mexican banks in transfer heist
All news
SafeUM
Confidential Terms of Use Our technologies Company
Follow us
Download
SafeUM © Safe Universal Messenger

Axarhöfði 14,
110 Reykjavik, Iceland

Iceland - 2015